Boushel 2013 Int J Biochem Cell Biol
From Bioblast
Revision as of 15:43, 12 August 2013 by Gnaiger Erich (talk | contribs)
Boushel RC, Saltin B (2012) Ex vivo measures of muscle mitochondrial capacity reveal quantitative limits of oxygen delivery by the circulation during exercise. Int J Biochem Cell Biol [Epub ahead of print]. |
Boushel RC, Saltin B (2012) Int J Biochem Cell Biol
Abstract:
Labels:
Epub ahead of print
Comment on Figures 2 and 3
- Fig. 2: The mitochondrial pathways shown in Fig. 2 are a direct copy of a figure made available by Erich Gnaiger to Robert Boushel (and A.N.) in the context of introductory O2k-Workshops and collaborations starting in 2003/2004. The figure is a preliminary and erroneous version of the published Figure (Gnaiger 2007), since FADH2 is shown on a comparable level with NADH, a frequently observed textbook error. The corrected figure (with Succinate and NADH on a comparable level) was published in 2007 and 2009 (Gnaiger 2007, 2009). The propagation of an erroneous figure is unfortunate, and the correct citation is missing in Boushel and Saltin (2012).
- Gnaiger E, ed (2007) Mitochondrial Pathways and Respiratory Control. OROBOROS MiPNet Publications, Innsbruck: 96 pp. Electronic 1st edition, ISBN: 978-3-9502399-0-4 - http://www.oroboros.at/?MiPNet-Publications
- Gnaiger E (2007-2001) Mitochondrial pathways through Complexes I+II: Convergent electron transport at the Q-junction and additive effect of substrate combinations. Mitochondr Physiol Network 12.12. - http://www.oroboros.at/?C1-and-2
- Fig. 3: No permission was ever given to reproduce the figure in this article. A proper citation is:
- Gnaiger E, Wright-Paradis C, Sondergaard H, Lundby C, Calbet JA, Saltin B, Helge J, Boushel R (2005) High-resolution respirometry in small biopsies of human muscle: correlations with body mass index and age. Mitochondr Physiol Network 10.9: 14-15. http://www.mitophysiology.org/?gnaigere.
- A clarification is required on the journal level.
- This comment is added here in the spirit of Gentle Science.
- Erich Gnaiger (2012-11-14)
Clarification by RC Boushel
- I have .. decided to write to the editor of IJBCB and retract our paper from the Journal. .. with sincere apologies, Rob (2012-11-15).
- I fully agree and will request .. to have these figures removed Rob (2012-11-17).