Talk:The protonmotive force and respiratory control: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 13:01, 11 August 2017

Work flow

2017-08-11: HK Lee: ‘Control’ should be defined. The chapter on protonmotive force is difficult to read.
2017-08-10: Version 10: Integration of suggestions and corrections by T Komlodi and A Meszaros.
2017-08-08 to 09: Updated versions by E Gnaiger.
2017-08-02: Updated ms summarizing WG1 input by J Iglesias-Gonzalez.
2017-08-29: Version 3 on website by E Gnaiger

http://www.mitoeagle.org/index.php/Mitochondrial_respiratory_control:_MITOEAGLE_recommendations_1

2017-07-28 to 29: Obergurgl MITOEAGLE Workshop: WG1 – group discussion and edits based on printed Version 2.
2017 Mar 21-23: Barcelona MITOEAGLE Workshop: WG1 – presentations and group discussions.

Feedback to MITOEAGLE today (2017-04-21)

Patrice Petit

Dear Eric,

I find the text clearly exposed even if the publicity for Mitoeagle is to much pronounced (but that is a choice).

Concerning:

State 1: depending on the fact that mitochondrial extract of isolated mitochondria is crude or purified (for exemple on Percoll gradients or sucrose gradients), the isolated mitochondria have still somes endogenous substrats or not that makes a pulse at the start during their early dissipation. Could this be taken into consideration or being indiscted for the users.

State 4: I do not find this very well writen since after the addition of ADP (state 3) the mitochondrial membrane potential drop and reacquire its high value (at the state 4) when all the ADP has been transformed in ATP has been used? am I wrong. So this shoul be writen clearly.

Why escaping to state about CR (respiratory control) and ADP/O measurements and definitions?

Again, I perfectly understand the reference to the bioblast link by since we do not live outside teh real world the reference are usually referred to pubmed also... so we should refer to both...

For te publication, the suggestion is nice but by tradition our journals are more....

BBA general subjects or bioenergetic: 6554 occurrences
FEBS J: 2911 FEBS letters 2563 (so 1+2 = 5474 Occurrences)
Journal of Biological Chemistry: 7730 occurrences

My personnal preference will go To BBA general subjects... But should be decided in commun

Sincerely yours

Patrice - Petit PX

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
+== Work flow ==
+* 2017-08-11: HK Lee: ‘Control’ should be defined. The chapter on protonmotive force is difficult to read.
+* 2017-08-10: Version 10: Integration of suggestions and corrections by T Komlodi and A Meszaros.
+* 2017-08-08 to 09: Updated versions by E Gnaiger.
+* 2017-08-02: Updated ms summarizing WG1 input by J Iglesias-Gonzalez.
+* 2017-08-29: Version 3 on website by E Gnaiger
+	http://www.mitoeagle.org/index.php/Mitochondrial_respiratory_control:_MITOEAGLE_recommendations_1
+* 2017-07-28 to 29: Obergurgl MITOEAGLE Workshop: WG1 – group discussion and edits based on printed Version 2.
+* 2017 Mar 21-23: Barcelona MITOEAGLE Workshop: WG1 – presentations and group discussions.
 == Feedback to MITOEAGLE today (2017-04-21) ==