Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. More information

Difference between revisions of "Talk:SUIT-029"

From Bioblast
 
(20 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{MitoPedia
{{MitoPedia
|abbr=
|abbr=
|description=[[File:1PM;2D;3Omy;4U.png|400px|SUIT-029]]
|description=[[File:1PM;2T;3Omy;4U.png|400px|SUIT-029]]
|info='''A: quality control evaluation of [[mitochondrial preparations]]''' - '''[[SUIT-029]]'''
|info='''A: quality control evaluation of [[mitochondrial preparations]]''' - '''[[SUIT-029]]'''
}}
}}
Line 12: Line 12:
{{MitoPedia O2k and high-resolution respirometry}}
{{MitoPedia O2k and high-resolution respirometry}}
{{MitoPedia topics}}
{{MitoPedia topics}}
:::: '''[[SUIT protocol pattern]]''': 1PM;2T;3Omy;4U-
::::The SUIT-029 protocol  is specially designed to evaluate the quality of [[Mitochondrial preparations| mitochondrial preparations]]  in a wide variety of species, tissues and cell types. SUIT-029 gives information of the linear coupling control ([[LEAK respiration|''L'']]-[[Oxidative phosphorylation| ''P'']]-[[ET capacity| ''E'']]) with NADH linked-substrates ([[PM-pathway control state|PM]]). Using this protocol ATPase contamination and mitochondrial outer membrane integrity in different [[Mitochondrial preparations| mitochondrial preparations]] with [[N-pathway control state|N substrates]] can be evaluated. In isolated mitochondria contaminated by ATPases, endogenous adenylates are phosphorylated to ATP in the LEAK state, which is recycled to ADP, which leads to an overestimation of LEAK respiration, when comparing  [[LEAK_state_with_oligomycin |''L(Omy)'']] and [[LEAK_state_without_adenylates | ''L(n)'']]. Therefore, it might be necessary to assess LEAK respiration in the presence of ATPases inhibitors, ''e.g.'' oligomycin. Optionally, [[additive effect of convergent electron flow]] through [[N-pathway control state|NADH-]] and [[NS-pathway control state| NS-pathways]] can be evaluated  in the [[ET capacity| ET state]].


:::: '''[[SUIT protocol pattern]]''': 1PM;2D;3Omy;4U-
::::The present SUIT-029 DLP file shows an application in with imt, thom and pce in the pathway category in N or NS. For using this protocol with other sample preparations or substrate/inhibitor combinations, a personalized [[Export DL-Protocol User (*.DLPU)|DLPU]] can be created.
The SUIT-029 protocol  is specially designed to evaluate the quality of [[Mitochondrial preparations| mitochondrial preparations]]  in a wide variety of species, tissues and cell types. SUIT-029 gives information of the linear coupling control ([[LEAK-respiration|''L'']]-[[Oxidative phosphorylation| ''P'']]-[[ET-capacity| ''E'']]) with NADH linked-substrates ([[PM pathway control state|PM]]). With this protocol ATPase contamination and mitochondrial outer membrane integrity in different [[Mitochondrial preparations| mitochondrial preparations]] with [[N-pathway control state|N substrates]] can be evaluated.  Moreover, the LEAK state [[LEAK_state_with_oligomycin |L(Omy)]] without the uncoupling promoted by the ATPase contamination and as a control with the [[LEAK_state_without_adenylates | L(n)]] previously obtained is also assessed. As a test for limitation of [[OXPHOS-capacity | OXPHOS capacity]] by the phosphorylation system relative to [[ET-capacity | ET-capacity]] the performance of [[ Uncoupler_titrations | uncoupler titrations]] might be carried out with [[NADH_Electron_transfer-pathway_state|N]] in order to calculate [[ET-coupling_efficiency | ET-coupling efficiency (1-L/E)]]. The additive effect of convergent flux through [[N-pathway control state|NADH-linked respiration]],[[NS-pathway control state| NS]], and [[Succinate pathway control state| S]] in [[ET-capacity| ''E'']] can be evaluated by using this protocol.  
__TOC__
__TOC__
  Communicated by [[Antunes D]], [[Komlodi T]], [[Gnaiger E]] (last update 2020-03-06)
  Communicated by [[Antunes D]], [[Komlodi T]], [[Gnaiger E]] (last update 2020-05-12)
== Specific SUIT protocols ==
== Specific SUIT protocols ==


Line 22: Line 23:


[[File:1PM;2T;2D;2c;3Omy;4U;5G;6S;6U;7Rot;8Ama.png|400px]]
[[File:1PM;2T;2D;2c;3Omy;4U;5G;6S;6U;7Rot;8Ama.png|400px]]
 
[[File:SUIT-029 mt D066 traces.png|400px]]
[[File:SUIT-029 O2 mt D066 traces.png|400px]]


*  [[SUIT-029 O2 mt D066]] for [[Isolated mitochondria|isolated mitochondria]], [[Tissue homogenate|tissue homogenate]] and [[Permeabilized cells|permeabilized cells]] (already permeabilized when they are added to the chamber)
*  [[SUIT-029 O2 mt D066]] for [[Isolated mitochondria|isolated mitochondria]], [[Tissue homogenate|tissue homogenate]] and [[Permeabilized cells|permeabilized cells]] (already permeabilized when they are added to the chamber)
{{Template:SUIT-029 O2 mt D066}}
{{Template:SUIT-029 O2 mt D066}}
== Strengths and limitations ==
== Strengths and limitations ==
:::* This protocol allows to evaluate the quality of [[mitochondrial preparations]] taking into account the presence of ATPases.
:::* This protocol allows to evaluate the quality of [[mitochondrial preparations]] taking into account the presence of ATPases.
:::+ Linear coupling control (''L''-''P''-''E'') with N substrates (PM). [[N-pathway control state|N substrates]] (PM) make use of all the proton pumps in the ETS without the additivity effect of the S-pathway, which would decrease the coupling degree. Additionally, PM is the superior alternative to GM: the fraction of the N-pathway is lower and S-pathway contribution is higher with GM compared to PM. PM, therefore, yields a more sensitive assay for the diagnosis of injuries in the N-pathway, since impairment of N-pathway capacity can be compensated partially by activation of the S-pathway.
:::::::+ PM is the superior alternative to GM: with GM the fraction of the N-pathway is lower and S-pathway contribution is higher compared to PM. PM, therefore, yields a more sensitive assay for the diagnosis of injuries in the N-pathway, since in the case of GM impairment N-pathway capacity can be compensated partially by activation of the S-pathway.
:::+[[OXPHOS]] capacity evaluation is included (2D).
:::::::+ Evaluation of the ATPase contamination is included (2T).
:::::::+ Integrity of mitochondrial outer membrane is assessed ( 2''c'').
:::::::+ Overestimation of [[LEAK respiration]] is prevented in the presence of [[Oligomycin]] as a control with the ''L''(n) previously obtained.
:::::::+ Evaluation of ET-state with NADH-linked substrates allows to calculate ET-coupling efficiency (1-''L''/''E'').
:::::::+ This protocol can be extended with the Complex IV module.
:::::::- Long duration of the experiment due to adjustment of [[Oligomycin]] concentration (in the case of a new isolation protocol).  For a shorter protocol the titration of glutamate, succinate and rotenone could be omitted.
:::::::- The use of [[Oligomycin]] could affect the evaluation of the ET capacity (could inhibit ET-state).
:::::::- Careful washing is required after the experiment to avoid carry-over of inhibitors and uncoupler.


:::+ Evaluation of the ATPase contamination is included (2T).
== Compare SUIT protocols ==
::::* [[SUIT-001]] (RP1): Harmonized SUIT protocol for isolated mitochondria, tissue homogenate and permeabilized cells.
::::* [[SUIT-006]]: Very short coupling protocol with PM as NADH-linked substrates.
::::* [[SUIT-008]]: A protocol to evaluate NS-linked pathway in the OXPHOS and ET states.
::::* [[SUIT-004]]: Short version of RP1; without G, F and Gp.
::::* [[SUIT-012]]: Coupling control with NADH-linked substrates (PM and PGM) without Omy addition.


:::+ The integrity of mitochondrial outer membrane is assessed ( 2''c'').
:::+ [[LEAK]] respiration overestimation is prevented in the presence of [[Oligomycin]], without the uncoupling promoted by the ATPase contamination and as a control with the ''L''(n) previously obtained.
:::+ Internal [[ET-pathway]] control step is included as a test for limitation of OXPHOS-capacity by the phosphorylation system relative to ET-capacity. The evaluation of ET-state with NADH-linked substrates allows to calculate ET-coupling efficiency (1-''L''/''E'').
:::+ The additive effect of convergent flux through NADH-linked respiration in ET-state is evaluated (5G).
:::+ ET-state with NS-linked substrates is evaluated (5S) followed by additional U titration to ensure ET-capacity.
:::+ Assessment of ET-capacity not only in N- and NS-pathway but also in S-pathway (7Rot).
:::+ This protocol can be optionally harmonized with many other SUIT protocols (''e.g''., SUIT-001, SUIT-004, SUIT-008). Addition of [[Glutamate|G]] in NADH-supported [[Oxidative phosphorylation| OXPHOS]] enables evaluation of the [[glutamate anaplerotic pathway control state]].
:::+ This protocol can be extended with the Complex IV module.
:::- Long duration of the experiment due to adjustment of [[Oligomycin]] concentration (in the case of a new isolation protocol).  For a shorter protocol the titration of glutamate, succinate and rotenone could be omitted.
:::- The use of [[Oligomycin]] could affect the evaluation of the ET capacity (could inhibit ET-state).
:::- F-pathway is not analysed.
:::- Careful washing is required after the experiment to avoid carry-over of inhibitors and uncoupler.
== Compare SUIT protocols ==
::::* [[SUIT-001 O2 mt D001]] (RP1): Harmonized SUIT protocol for isolated mitochondria, tissue homogenate and permeabilized cells (already permeabilized).
::::* [[SUIT-002 O2 mt D005]] (RP2): Harmonized SUIT protocol for isolated mitochondria, tissue homogenate and permeabilized cells (already permeabilized).


== References ==
== References ==

Latest revision as of 12:44, 25 November 2020


high-resolution terminology - matching measurements at high-resolution


Talk:SUIT-029

Description

SUIT-029


Reference: A: quality control evaluation of mitochondrial preparations - SUIT-029


MitoPedia concepts: MiP concept, SUIT protocol, Recommended 


MitoPedia methods: Respirometry 




SUIT protocol pattern: 1PM;2T;3Omy;4U-
The SUIT-029 protocol is specially designed to evaluate the quality of mitochondrial preparations in a wide variety of species, tissues and cell types. SUIT-029 gives information of the linear coupling control (L- P- E) with NADH linked-substrates (PM). Using this protocol ATPase contamination and mitochondrial outer membrane integrity in different mitochondrial preparations with N substrates can be evaluated. In isolated mitochondria contaminated by ATPases, endogenous adenylates are phosphorylated to ATP in the LEAK state, which is recycled to ADP, which leads to an overestimation of LEAK respiration, when comparing L(Omy) and L(n). Therefore, it might be necessary to assess LEAK respiration in the presence of ATPases inhibitors, e.g. oligomycin. Optionally, additive effect of convergent electron flow through NADH- and NS-pathways can be evaluated in the ET state.
The present SUIT-029 DLP file shows an application in with imt, thom and pce in the pathway category in N or NS. For using this protocol with other sample preparations or substrate/inhibitor combinations, a personalized DLPU can be created.
Communicated by Antunes D, Komlodi T, Gnaiger E (last update 2020-05-12)

Specific SUIT protocols

SUIT-029 O2 mt D066

1PM;2T;2D;2c;3Omy;4U;5G;6S;6U;7Rot;8Ama.png SUIT-029 mt D066 traces.png

MitoPedia: SUIT

Steps and respiratory states

1PM;2T;2D;2c;3Omy;4U;5G;6S;6U;7Rot;8Ama.png


Step State Pathway Q-junction Comment - Events (E) and Marks (M)


1PM PML(n) N CI 1PM
2T PML or PMP N CI 1PM;2T
  • NADH-linked substrates (type N-pathway to Q).
  • In the absence of ATPase activity, the LEAK-state is maintained. However, if ATPases are active and thus generate ADP, respiration coupled to phosphorylation is stimulated. Stimulation is limited up to OXPHOS-capacity; therefore, higher ATPase activities cannot be determined.
2D PMP N CI 1PM;2T;2D
2c PMcP N CI 1PM;2T;2D;2c
3Omy PMLOmy N CI 1PM;2D;2c;3Omy
  • NADH-linked substrates (type N-pathway to Q).
  • Non-phosphorylating resting state (LEAK state); LEAK-respiration, L(Omy), after blocking the ATP synthase with oligomycin.
4U PME N CI 1PM;2T;2D;2c;3Omy;4U
5G PGME N CI 1PM;2T;2D;2c;3Omy;4U;5G
6S PGMSE NS CI+CII 1PM;2T;2D;2c;3Omy;4U;5G;6S
  • Respiratory stimulation by simultaneous action of type N substrates & succinate, with convergent electron flow in the NS-pathway for reconstitution of TCA cycle function.
  • Noncoupled electron transfer state, ET state, with ET capacity E.
6U PGMSE NS CI+CII 1PM;2T;2D;2c;3Omy;4U;5G;6S;6U
7Rot SE S CI 1PM;2T;2D;2c;3Omy;4U;5G;6S;6U;7Rot
8Ama ROX 1PM;2T;2D;2c;3Omy;4U;5G;6S;6U;7Rot;8Ama
  • Rox is the residual oxygen consumption in the ROX state, due to oxidative side reactions, estimated after addition of antimycin A (inhibitor of CIII). Rox is subtracted from oxygen flux as a baseline for all respiratory states, to obtain mitochondrial respiration (mt).


Questions.jpg


Click to expand or collaps

Strengths and limitations

+ PM is the superior alternative to GM: with GM the fraction of the N-pathway is lower and S-pathway contribution is higher compared to PM. PM, therefore, yields a more sensitive assay for the diagnosis of injuries in the N-pathway, since in the case of GM impairment N-pathway capacity can be compensated partially by activation of the S-pathway.
+ Evaluation of the ATPase contamination is included (2T).
+ Integrity of mitochondrial outer membrane is assessed ( 2c).
+ Overestimation of LEAK respiration is prevented in the presence of Oligomycin as a control with the L(n) previously obtained.
+ Evaluation of ET-state with NADH-linked substrates allows to calculate ET-coupling efficiency (1-L/E).
+ This protocol can be extended with the Complex IV module.
- Long duration of the experiment due to adjustment of Oligomycin concentration (in the case of a new isolation protocol). For a shorter protocol the titration of glutamate, succinate and rotenone could be omitted.
- The use of Oligomycin could affect the evaluation of the ET capacity (could inhibit ET-state).
- Careful washing is required after the experiment to avoid carry-over of inhibitors and uncoupler.

Compare SUIT protocols

  • SUIT-001 (RP1): Harmonized SUIT protocol for isolated mitochondria, tissue homogenate and permeabilized cells.
  • SUIT-006: Very short coupling protocol with PM as NADH-linked substrates.
  • SUIT-008: A protocol to evaluate NS-linked pathway in the OXPHOS and ET states.
  • SUIT-004: Short version of RP1; without G, F and Gp.
  • SUIT-012: Coupling control with NADH-linked substrates (PM and PGM) without Omy addition.


References